As you read this excerpt about Nietzsche's life, consider how Nietzsche's rejection of traditional values reflected existential concerns. How is Nietzsche similar to, yet different from, the figures you have studied so far in this course?
Questioning Rationality
Nietzsche
also questioned the entire philosophical tradition of the West, which
developed based on trust in the power of reason. He asked: Isn't there a
deeper unconscious motive underneath the exercise of reason? Is a
theory not a matter of justification, an invention in order to conceal
that motive? Is a human being not far more complex than a mere rational
being? Can rationality be the root of philosophical discourse? Is
thinking not dominated by other forces in consciousness, forces one is
not aware of? Did Western philosophy not take the wrong path? Thus,
Nietzsche questions the way Western philosophy has developed and its
trust in rationality that can be traced back to Greek philosophy.
Nietzsche
was prophetic in the sense that he raised fundamental questions about
the two key traditions of the West - Christianity and philosophy. His life
was tragic, because not only could no one answer him, but also no one
understood the authenticity of his questions. Even his well-known
phrase, "God is dead," has a tragic tone.
Nietzsche
grew up as an innocent and faithful child nicknamed the "small priest,"
singing hymns and citing biblical verses in front of others. When he
was ten or twelve, he expressed his question about God in an essay
entitled "Destiny and History." In Daybreak (Book I), which Nietzsche
wrote right after his resignation from professorship, he asks, "Would he
not be a cruel god if he possessed the truth and could behold mankind
miserably tormenting itself over the truth?" (Clark 92). The question,
if God is almighty, why did he not simply tell us the truth and save us,
who were terribly suffering and seeking for truth, is a question we all
may have had in our mind. In the phrase, "God is dead," don't we hear
Nietzsche's tormented heart asking God to answer the question?
Nietzsche
is among the most readable of philosophers and penned a large number of
aphorisms and varied experimental forms of composition. Although his
work was distorted and thus identified with Philosophical Romanticism,
Nihilism, Anti-Semitism, and even Nazism, he himself vociferously denied
such tendencies in his work, even to the point of directly opposing
them. In philosophy and literature, he is often identified as an
inspiration for existentialism and postmodernism. His thought is, by
many accounts, most difficult to comprehend in any systematized form and
remains a vivacious topic of debate.