Crafting Strong Arguments
Using Support and Creating Arguments
Key Takeaways
- Speakers often use facts and statistics to
reinforce or demonstrate information. Unfortunately, many speakers and
audience members do not have a strong mathematical background, so it is
important to understand the statistics used and communicate this
information to the audience.
- Speakers use definitions - which may be lexical,
persuasive, stipulative, or theoretical - to clarify their messages.
Lexical definitions state how a word is used within a given language.
Persuasive definitions are devised to express a word or term in a
specific persuasive manner. Stipulative definitions are created when a
word or term is coined. Theoretical definitions attempt to describe all
parts related to a particular type of idea or object.
- Examples - positive, negative, non, and best - help
the audience grasp a concept. Positive examples are used to clarify or
clearly illustrate a principle, method, or phenomenon. Negative examples
show how not to behave in a specific situation. Nonexamples are used to
express what something is not. Best examples show the best way someone
should behave in a situation.
- Narratives can be used in all three general
purposes of speaking: informative, persuasive, and entertaining.
Informative narratives provide information or explanations about a
speaker's topic. Persuasive narratives are stories a speaker can use to
get his or her audience to accept or reject a specific attitude, value,
belief, or behavior. Entertaining narratives are stories that are
designed purely to delight an audience. Speakers have an ethical
obligation to let the audience know whether a narrative is true or
hypothetical.
- Expert testimony is an account given by someone
who is a recognized expert on a given topic. Eyewitness testimony is an
account given by an individual who has had firsthand experience with a
specific phenomenon or idea. Explaining the context of the testimony is
important so your audience can evaluate the likelihood that the
testimony is accurate, current, and unbiased.
- Analogies, both figurative and literal, can help
audiences understand unfamiliar concepts. Figurative analogies compare
two ideas or objects from two different classes. Conversely, literal
analogies compare two objects or ideas that clearly belong to the same
class. Speakers using analogies need to make sure that the audience will
be able to see the similarity between the objects or ideas being
compared.