Visual Ageism in the Media
Read through this chapter on ageism in the media.
Introduction
Since the introduction of the term "ageism" in
the literature by Butler, the number of studies documenting the
process of systematic stereotyping and discrimination against people
because they are old, and analysing the way these stereotypes are shared
in the population and how they persist over time, has continued to expand. In this chapter, we analyse
representations of older people in the visual media - print
advertisements, television advertisements, and television programs. We
examine whether older people are represented as third agers, who are
active, enjoy life, and who maintain a healthy life style, which are all
part of the successful ageing discourse, or as
fourth agers, who are inactive and unable to live independently. We
assess empirical evidence that suggests a shift away from negative
representations of older adults in visual media towards more positive
representations, and illustrate the way in which this change has
occurred in advertisements and television programs.
Previous
media studies research has mainly focused on the frequency with which
women and various minority groups are characterized in television
content and advertisements. In media research, ageism, like other forms
of stereotype, is seen as "a coherent set of shared ideas and beliefs
that constitutes a particular justification of the interests of dominant
groups: the state, employers, hospitals, media". Albeit not explicitly, media studies have approached ageism as an
asymmetric power structure based on age, a constructed justification of
inequalities between age groups, by focusing on
groups that are systematically under- or misrepresented in the media.
They criticize the negative representation of older adults in the media,
including the fact that they are often only given minor or peripheral
roles and that they are portrayed with no positive attributes, and argue
in favour of more positive, more realistic and nuanced representation,
in which the portrayals of older adults more accurately reflect the
characteristics of the audience.
Media content, including visual
media, is a continuous reflection of societal practices. It influences
everyday interactions, including the way we relate to older people, as
well as the way we see ourselves as "being old". Media representations
offer a means to examine the logic according to which the social
construction of ageing is made and maintained.
However, media studies are often criticized for the overuse of content
analysis as a method, the lack of theoretical discussion,
and the fact that they focus on the sender and neglect the receiver in
the communication process. To address some of these issues, ageism
researchers have started to document the frequency of stereotypic
representations from a communicative perspective, regarding aging as an
interactive process between society and the individual.
We coined the term "visual ageism" to describe
the social practice of visually underrepresenting older people or
misrepresenting them in a prejudiced way. We believe that this concept
could be useful in researching the way older people are presented in
visual media content. Visual ageism includes
older adults being depicted in peripheral or minor roles without
positive attributes; non-realistic, exaggerated, or distorted portraits
of older people; and over-homogenized characterizations of older adults.
At the end of this chapter, we discuss an alternative to reduce visual
ageism: the "design for diversity" approach.