Strategy through Organizational Design

This resource presents the four types of organizational structures (simple, functional, multi-divisional, and matrix) and gives examples of companies that have used them. It then explores some of the newer ideas about organizational design and delves into the reasons to change for setting up control systems. Note the discussion on management fads.

Creating Organizational Control Systems

Clan Control

Instead of measuring results (as in outcome control) or dictating behavior (as in behavioral control), clan control is an informal type of control. Specifically, clan control relies on shared traditions, expectations, values, and norms to lead people to work toward the good of their organization. Clan control is often used heavily in settings where creativity is vital, such as in high-tech businesses. In these companies, output is tough to dictate, and many rules are not appropriate. The creativity of a research scientist would be likely to be stifled, for example, if she were given a quota of patents that she must meet each year (output control) or if a strict dress code were enforced (behavioral control).

Google relies on clan control, employees are permitted to spend 20 percent of their workweek on their own innovative projects. The company offers an "ideas mailing list'' for employees to submit new ideas and to comment on others' ideas. Google executives routinely make themselves available two to three times per week for employees to visit with them to present their ideas. These informal meetings have generated a number of innovations, including personalized home pages and Google News, which might otherwise have never been adopted.

Some executives look to clan control to improve the performance of struggling organizations. In 2005, Florida officials became fed up with complaints about surly clerks within the state's driver's license offices. Their solution was to look for help with training employees from two companies that are well-known for friendly, engaged employees and excellent customer service:  Walt Disney Company and the regional supermarket chain Publix (their motto stressed that "shopping is a pleasure" in its stores). The goal of the training was to build the sort of positive team spirit. The state's highway safety director summarized the need for clan control when noting that "we've just got to change a little culture out there".