ARTH101: Art Appreciation

Frank Lloyd Wright, Fallingwater (Edgar J. Kaufmann House), 1935-38, Bear Run, Pennsylvania

Perched above a mountain cataract on a rocky hillside deep in the rugged forest of Southwestern Pennsylvania, some 90 minutes from Pittsburgh, is America's most famous house. The commission for Fallingwater was a personal milestone for the American architect Frank Lloyd Wright since it clearly marked a turning point in his career. After this late-career triumph, the 67-year-old would create a series of highly original designs to validate his claim as "The world's greatest architect."

The mid-1930s were among the darkest years for architecture and architects in American history; the country's financial system had collapsed with the failure of hundreds of banks. Almost no private homes were built. Many of the architectural projects started during the boom of the late 1920s were halted for lack of funds. In his sixties, Wright and his new wife Olgivanna struggled to keep Taliesin, his Wisconsin home and studio, out of foreclosure. Worse still, his peers were beginning to regard Wright as an irrelevant anachronism whose time had passed.

In 1932 Henry-Russell Hitchcock and Philip Johnson opened the "Modern Architecture: International Exhibition" at the newly founded Museum of Modern Art in New York and simultaneously published the book International Style. This was, perhaps, the most influential architectural exhibit ever mounted in the United States, and the book became a manifesto for modern architecture and would profoundly affect almost every major architectural project worldwide for the next 30 years. It focused on the work of four great "European functionalists," Walter Gropius, Ludwig Mies van der Rohe, Le Corbusier, and J.J.P. Oud. Wright was largely snubbed.

Hitchcock had praised his early work for its "many innovations" but condemned Wright for a "[l]ack of continuity in his development and his unwillingness to absorb the innovations of his contemporaries and his juniors in Europe." Hitchcock insulted Wright further by characterizing him as "a rebel by temperament… [who] refused even the discipline of his own theories." The catalog calls Wright a "half-modern" throwback, one of the "last representatives of Romanticism." Wright responded by denigrating European Modernism as an "evil crusade," a manifestation of "totalitarianism."

A Fellowship and a Commission

The Wrights devised an architectural apprenticeship program that came to be known as the "fellowship." Among the first candidates was Edgar Kaufmann Jr., who became enamored with Wright after reading his biography. Kaufmann was the son of Pittsburgh department store tycoon Edgar Kaufmann Sr., whose 13-story downtown Pittsburgh emporium was reported to be the largest in the world. Kaufmann senior was no stranger to architectural pursuits – he was involved in numerous public projects and built several stores and homes. Kaufmann let Wright know that he had several civic architectural projects in mind for him. He and his wife Liliane were invited to Taliesin and were duly impressed.

Fallingwater floorplan (diagram: Arsenalbubs: CC0 1.0)

There are varying accounts regarding the circumstances that brought Kaufmann to offer Wright a chance to design a "weekend home" in the country, but we know that Wright made his first trip to the site on Bear Run, Pennsylvania, in December 1934. Wright's apprentice Donald Hoppen has spoken of Wright's "uncanny sense of...genius loci" (Latin for "spirit of the place"), and from the beginning, the architect rejected a site that presented a conventional view of the waterfall; instead, he audaciously offered to make the house part of it, stating that the "visit to the waterfall in the woods stays with me and a domicile takes shape in my mind to the music of the stream." The South-southeast orientation gives the illusion that the stream flows not alongside the house but through it.

Frank Lloyd Wright, Fallingwater, steps to stream (Edgar J. Kaufmann House), Bear Run, Pennsylvania.

Fastest Draw in the Midwest

Perhaps the most famous tale to come out of the lore of Fallingwater is the improbable story that Wright, after receiving the commission, procrastinated for nine months until he was forced to draw up the complete plans while his patron was driving the 140 miles from Milwaukee to Taliesin. However, the essential story is validated by several witnesses. Apprentice Edgar Taffel recalled that after talking with Kaufmann on the phone, Wright "briskly emerged from his office...sat down at the table with the plot plan and started to draw…The design just poured out of him. "Liliane and E.J. will have tea on the balcony…they'll cross the bridge to walk in the woods…" Pencils being used up as fast as we can sharpen them...Erasures, overdrawing, modifying. Flipping sheets back and forth. Then, the bold title across the bottom is "Fallingwater." A house has to have a name." There seems to be agreement that the whole process took about two hours.

Frank Lloyd Wright, Fallingwater (Edgar J. Kaufmann House), Mill Run, Pennsylvania, 1935, Color pencil on tracing paper, 15-3/8 x 27-1/4 inches, © The Frank Lloyd Wright Foundation

Organic Architecture

Edgar Kaufmann Jr. pointed out that Wright's famous concept of "Organic Architecture" stems from his Transcendentalist background. The belief that human life is part of nature. Wright even incorporated a rock outcropping that projected above the living room floor into his massive central hearth, further uniting the house with the earth. "Can you say," Wright challenged his apprentices, "when your building is complete, that the landscape is more beautiful than it was before?"

In his book Fallingwater Rising: Frank Lloyd Wright, E. J. Kaufmann, and America's Most Extraordinary House, Franklin Toker wrote that

Frank Lloyd Wright, Fallingwater (Edgar J. Kaufmann House), Bear Run, Pennsylvania, 1937

Wright further emphasizes the connection with nature through the liberal use of glass; the house has no walls facing the falls, only a central stone core for the fireplaces and stone columns. This provides elongated vistas leading the eye to the horizon and the woods. Vincent Scully has pointed out that this reflects "an image of Modern man caught up in constant change and flow, holding on…to whatever seems solid but no longer regarding himself as the center of the world". The architect's creative use of "corner-turning windows" without mullions causes corners to vanish. Wright bows to nature by bending a trellis beam to accommodate a pre-existing tree.

Frank Lloyd Wright, Fallingwater, detail with tree (Edgar J. Kaufmann House), 1937

Influences

Although he denied it, Wright was influenced by every conceivable architectural style, but Fallingwater owes little to his previous designs (the only exceptions being perhaps the use of irregular stones also found on Taliesin and his interest in strong horizontal lines). At Fallingwater, he appears to be more concerned with responding to the European Modernist design that he had partly inspired but had since eclipsed him. In effect, he set out to beat the Europeans at their own game, using elements of their idiom.

Walter Gropius and Adolf Meyer, competition entry for the Chicago Tribune Tower, 1922, perspective drawing, 22.5 x 13.3cm, gelatin silver print sheet (Harvard Art Museums)

We see, for example, inspiration drawn from the balconies of Gropius' design for the Chicago Tribune Tower competition, though instead of the stark white of the International Style, he paints his balconies a warmer, earthen tone in deference to nature and perhaps the Adobe dwellings of the American Southwest.

Fallingwater Falling Down?

The Kaufmanns loved Wright's radical proposal to suspend the house over the waterfall literally. But Edgar Kaufmann Sr., ever the pragmatic businessman (who had also studied engineering for a year at Yale), prudently sent a copy of Wright's blueprints to his engineer, who found the ground unstable and did not recommend that he proceed with the house. Wright was not happy with his client's lack of faith but permitted an increase in the number and diameter of the structure's steel reinforcements – Kaufmann agreed to proceed. It is worth noting that the engineer's warnings later proved valid, an issue that "haunted" Wright for the rest of his life.

Frank Lloyd Wright, Frederick C. Robie House, Historic American Buildings Survey, Cervin Robinson, Photographer, 18 August 1963, exterior from the southwest, 5757 Woodlawn Avenue, Chicago, Cook County, IL 5 x 7 inches (Library of Congress HABS ILL,16-CHIG,33--3)

Wright is famous for pushing the architectural envelope for dramatic effect. We see this in the vast cantilevered wooden roof of Robie House in Chicago. In Fallingwater, he chose ferroconcrete for his cantilevers; this use of reinforced concrete for the long suspended balconies was revolutionary. He boldly extended the balcony of the second-floor master bedroom, soaring six feet beyond the living room below.

Frank Lloyd Wright, Fallingwater, steps to stream (Edgar J. Kaufmann House), Bear Run, Pennsylvania

However, due to the lack of proper support, cracks began appearing on the balcony floors soon after they were poured. Over the years, cracks have been repeatedly repaired as the cantilevers continued to sag. By 2001 some of the 15-foot cantilevers had fallen more than 7 inches. To avoid a complete collapse, an ingenious system was devised using tensioned cables to correct the problem and stabilize Wright's masterwork.

Almost from the day of its completion, Fallingwater was celebrated around the world. The house and its architect were featured in major publications, including the cover of Time Magazine. Over the years, its fame has only increased. According to Franklin Toker, Fallingwater's most important contribution to Modern Architecture is the "acceptance of Modern architecture itself."

Source: Charles Wiebe, https://www.khanacademy.org/humanities/ap-art-history/later-europe-and-americas/modernity-ap/a/frank-lloyd-wright-fallingwater
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 License.